The History of AI

The conditioned reflex

Era 1 · The foundations (1763–1942) › Neuroscience and the psychology of learning

Lineage
Acting in the world
Kind
Theory

Who

Military Medical Academy, St. Petersburg

What happened

On April 23, 1903, at the International Medical Congress in Madrid, Ivan Pavlov presents "Experimental Psychology and Psychopathology in Animals": a dog learns to salivate at a signal that announces food.

Why it mattered

The first public account of classical conditioning: a neutral stimulus, repeatedly paired with one that triggers a response, comes to trigger the response on its own. Along with the law of effect, it is the other basic form of associative learning.

The full story

Ivan Pavlov, a physiologist in St. Petersburg, studied digestion in dogs whose saliva and gastric juices could be measured. Repeating the experiments revealed something that spoiled the measurements: the dogs began to salivate before they got their food, at the sight of the assistant who brought it or the sound of the assistant's footsteps. Pavlov at first called this "psychic secretion."

Instead of discarding it, Pavlov made it the object of study. If an arbitrary signal, such as the sound of a metronome, is presented several times just before the food, the dog ends up salivating at the signal alone. Pavlov distinguished the innate reflex, salivating at food, from the acquired one, salivating at the signal, which exists only because the two have been presented together. If the signal is repeated without food, the response dies away.

Pavlov first presented these ideas to the international community on April 23, 1903, at the 14th International Medical Congress, held in Madrid. The next year came the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine, though for the work on digestion. The book Conditioned Reflexes, of 1927, brought three decades of experiments together in English.

Classical conditioning and Thorndike's law of effect are the two models of associative learning from which twentieth-century experimental psychology starts. Richard Sutton and Andrew Barto later developed temporal-difference learning partly as a model of this kind of conditioning.

Side by side

Two forms of associative learning
FeatureClassical conditioningLaw of effect
WhoPavlov (1903)Thorndike (1898)
What is associatedA signal with a stimulus that already triggers a responseA behavior with its consequence
The animalReceives the signalActs and gets a result
ExampleSalivates on hearing the metronomePresses the lever to get out of the box

Common misconceptions

  • What people often say: Pavlov conditioned the dogs with a bell.

    In fact: The experiments mostly used metronomes, buzzers, and other stimuli. The bell is the popular version of the story.

Leads to

  • Temporal differences (August 1988)

    Inherited, with no proven direct link

    Sutton and Barto also develop temporal-difference learning as a model of classical conditioning, the phenomenon Pavlov described

Sources

How to cite

“The conditioned reflex.” The History of AI, revised November 13, 2026. https://thehistoryofai.com/en/milestone/pavlov-conditioned-reflex

This entry was last reviewed on November 13, 2026.

Open in the interactive timeline