The History of AI

1974–1980

The first AI winter

Public funding for AI shrinks in the United States and the United Kingdom after a decade of broken promises.

What happened

In 1966 the ALPAC report concludes that machine translation is more expensive, less accurate, and slower than human translation, and the United States stops funding it. In 1973 the Lighthill report, commissioned by the British Science Research Council, states that "in no part of the field have the discoveries made so far produced the major impact that was then promised," and the United Kingdom withdraws support from almost all of its groups. From 1974 on, DARPA cuts academic AI research that lacks a clear military use, and in 1976 it ends its speech understanding program without a successor, even though Carnegie Mellon's HARPY system had met its goals.

Why

The promises of the 1960s ran into a limit Lighthill called the "combinatorial explosion": methods that solved small problems stopped working as the problems grew. The rules changed as well. After the Mansfield Amendment of 1969, DARPA had to fund research with a specific military purpose rather than open-ended basic research.

What kept going

The cuts did not reach the whole field. The historian Thomas Haigh points out that SIGART, the ACM's AI group, grew from 1,241 members in 1973 to about 3,500 by mid-1978, and Haigh argues that the 1970s were a decade of professionalization rather than collapse. Theoretical work on neural networks, which had lost support after the 1969 critique of the perceptron, carries on with little funding.

Why these dates

1974–1980 is the most common dating: it runs from the DARPA cuts to the arrival of commercial expert systems. Not everyone accepts it. Haigh argues that there was no general "first winter," only targeted cuts to machine translation, in the United Kingdom, and in the basic research DARPA paid for, and that the label has spread more through online summaries than through the work of historians. That is why the band dims only the lineage the documented cuts belong to.

Events that define it

Sources

Open in the interactive timeline